F29 System Wide Change: Make dbus-broker the default DBus implementation

= Proposed System Wide Change: Make dbus-broker the default DBus
implementation =
<a href="" title=""></a>

* David Herrmann <dh dot herrmann at gmail dot com>
* Tom Gundersen <teg at jklm dot no>

Enable dbus-broker.service to use dbus-broker as system and session
message bus backend.

== Detailed description ==
The dbus-broker project is an implementation of a message bus as
defined by the D-Bus specification. Its aim is to provide high
performance and reliability, while keeping compatibility to the D-Bus
reference implementation. It is exclusively written for linux systems,
and makes use of many modern features provided by recent linux kernel
The main focus points of dbus-broker are reliability, scalability and
security. The dbus-broker project tries to improve on these points
over dbus-daemon, and thus provide a better alternative. And in-depth
analysis can be found in the initial announcement of dbus-broker. An

* Accounting: dbus-broker maintains per-user accounting, including
inter-user quotas. This guarantees that no single user can cause
irregularly high memory consumption in the daemon. Unlike dbus-broker,
dbus-daemon accounts memory in a multi-tier system, based on plain
resource counters on users, connections, and other resources. The
multi-tier system suffers from resource-chaining-exhaustion, where
clients effectively circumvent the accounting by creating multiple
connections/objects, which themselves grant them each a new set of
quotas. The single-tier accounting scheme of dbus-broker avoids this,
while at the same time adding inter-user quotas to prevent misuse even
across clients.

* Reliability: While D-Bus is used on reliable transports, dbus-daemon
might still silently drop messages and given circumstances. This is
the only possible solution dbus-daemon has, given several of its
runtime guarantees. The dbus-broker project changed the architecture
of the bus daemon to a degree, that it can provide many guarantees,
including that no message will be silently, or unexpectedly, dropped.

* Scalability: The message bus broker is a crucial infrastructure on
modern linux system, which is a hot-path for almost all IPC going on.
Hence, the broker should perform fast and be scalable to its users.
dbus-daemon has several **global** data-structures that affect the
overall scalability of independent message transactions. dbus-broker
does not employ any global data-structures (unless required by the
spec), as such any message transaction is only affected by the data
provided by the involved peers. Moreover, even for spec-defined global
behavior, dbus-broker avoids global data-structures, unless clients
actually make use of these obscure features. In several other cases,
dbus-daemon scales O(n) time looking up message targets and related
data. dbus-broker runs all these in O(log(n)) time.

* Linux-specific: The dbus-broker project was explicitly designed for
linux system, making use of many linux-specific APIs and behavior.
This allows mitigation of several possible DoS attacks.

== Scope ==
* Proposal owners:
** Fix regressions.
** Enable dbus-broker.service in system and user-global context of
systemd (via systemd presets).
** Pull in dbus-broker package from dbus package.

* Other developers:
** Watch for regressions

* Release engineering: #7262 <a href="" title=""></a>

* List of deliverables:

* Policies and guidelines:
No changes needed.

* Trademark approval:
No changes needed.


Re: F29 System Wide Change: Make dbus-broker the default DBus im

By Zbigniew =?utf-... at 03/15/2018 - 04:59

FTR, patches to convert at-spi2-core to use dbus-broker:
<a href="" title=""></a>
<a href="" title=""></a>


On Tue, Mar 13, 2018 at 05:32:20PM +0100, Jan Kurik wrote:

Re: F29 System Wide Change: Make dbus-broker the default DBus im

By Steve Grubb at 03/13/2018 - 18:55


Just a quick question...dbus was patched to support SE Linux. I see no
mention of SE Linux support below. Does it replicate the same SE Linux


On Tue, 13 Mar 2018 17:32:20 +0100

Re: F29 System Wide Change: Make dbus-broker the default DBus im

By Tom Gundersen at 03/13/2018 - 19:52

On Tue, Mar 13, 2018 at 11:55 PM, Steve Grubb < ... at redhat dot com> wrote: